Coffee
← Blog Mac Productivity

Obsidian vs Notion 2027: Files on Your Mac vs the Cloud

By FavTray ·

Written by the team behind FavTray, a Mac developer dashboard for the menu bar. We check every app we cover against its own site, docs or a hands-on test, and each post says which.

Short answer: In Obsidian vs Notion, the real difference is where your notes live. Obsidian keeps plain Markdown files in a folder on your Mac, works fully offline and is free for everyone. Notion keeps a shared workspace on its servers, with databases, real-time collaboration and AI built in. Pick Obsidian for personal writing and long-term ownership; pick Notion for team work and databases.

TL;DR

  • Obsidian: free, local Markdown files, offline by default, plugins for almost everything. Sync is $4 a month billed yearly.
  • Notion: free for one person, then $10 or $20 per member a month. Databases, sharing and AI, but your workspace lives in Notion’s cloud.
  • Offline: Obsidian always; Notion only for pages you’ve downloaded.
  • Obsidian vs Apple Notes: Apple Notes wins on zero setup, Obsidian on files and linking.
  • Bear vs Obsidian: Bear is the nicer writing app on Apple devices; Obsidian is cross-platform and file-based.
  • Many people use both, with a quick-capture tool on the side.

We make FavTray, so weigh our take accordingly. FavTray isn’t a third contender here; it shows up only at the end, as a small notes tool you might keep next to either app. Prices were checked on obsidian.md/pricing and notion.com/pricing. Prices and versions are as of November 2026.

What’s the main difference between Obsidian and Notion?

Obsidian is a Markdown editor on top of a folder of files. Notion is a cloud database with pages on top. Everything else follows from that.

In Obsidian, a note is a .md file in a folder you pick (a “vault”). You can open it in any text editor, back it up with Time Machine, put it in git, or sync the folder with any service you trust. If Obsidian disappeared tomorrow, your notes would still open.

In Notion, a page is a set of blocks stored in Notion’s cloud. You need an account, and the desktop app is a window onto that workspace with an offline cache. In exchange you get things Obsidian can’t do well: shared pages that several people edit at once, permissions, comments, and databases with views, relations and formulas. If you’re setting up the app, our guide to the Notion desktop app for Mac covers the download and offline settings.

Obsidian vs Notion at a glance

ObsidianNotion
Where notes liveMarkdown files in a folder on your MacNotion’s cloud, with an offline cache
Account neededNo (only for Sync or Publish)Yes
Works offlineYes, alwaysPages you’ve marked or downloaded
Price for one personFreeFree (unlimited blocks for a single user)
Paid plansSync $4/mo yearly ($5 monthly), Publish $8/mo yearly ($10 monthly)Plus $10, Business $20 per member/mo (monthly), up to 20% off yearly
Commercial useFree; optional $50/user/year licencePaid plans per member
DatabasesBases and community pluginsBuilt in, with views, relations and formulas
CollaborationNot its focusReal-time editing, comments, permissions
AICommunity plugins, bring your own modelLimited trial on Free and Plus; full AI on Business and Enterprise
PlatformsMac, Windows, Linux, iOS, AndroidMac, Windows, web, iOS, Android

Prices and versions are as of November 2026.

How much does each one cost?

Obsidian is free “without limits”, and its pricing page says you are not required to pay for a commercial licence, so you can use it at work for free. The paid parts are optional:

  • Sync: $4 per user a month billed yearly, or $5 monthly. End-to-end encrypted sync between your devices.
  • Publish: $8 per site a month billed yearly, or $10 monthly, to put notes on the web.
  • Commercial licence: $50 per user per year, for organisations that want to support the project.
  • Catalyst: a one-time $25 for early-access builds.

You can skip Sync entirely by putting your vault in iCloud Drive or another folder sync, though Obsidian’s own Sync handles conflicts and version history better.

Notion’s pricing page lists Free, Plus at $10 and Business at $20 per member a month billed monthly, with up to 20% off for yearly billing, plus a custom Enterprise plan. Free gives a single user unlimited pages and blocks, 5 MB file uploads and 7 days of page history.

What about Notion AI? As of November 2026 it isn’t sold as a separate add-on. Free and Plus include a limited AI trial; Business and Enterprise include the full set, such as Notion Agent, AI Meeting Notes and Enterprise Search. Custom Agents are billed on top in Notion credits ($10 per 1,000 credits a month after a free trial). So if AI is the reason you want Notion, budget for Business at $20 per member a month, not Plus.

For one person, Obsidian with Sync costs $48 a year. Notion with full AI costs about $192 a year on yearly Business billing (up to 20% off $240). For a team of five, the gap is larger, though Obsidian isn’t really trying to be a team tool.

Which works better offline?

Obsidian, by a wide margin. Your vault is a folder on your disk, so there is nothing to download, no “available offline” switch and no sync to wait for. It behaves the same on a plane as at your desk.

Notion’s offline mode has improved. Since August 2025 you can mark a page available offline, and paid plans download Recents and Favorites automatically. On Free you choose pages yourself. Databases, embeds and some blocks are limited offline, and the main copy of your workspace is always on Notion’s servers. If “works offline” really means “my data is on my Mac”, read our list of local and offline Notion alternatives.

Which is better for writing, linking and organising?

Obsidian is built for connected notes. Type [[ to link to another note, see backlinks for every page, and browse a graph of how ideas connect. Daily notes, templates, tags and folders are built in. Bases adds database-style views over your notes’ properties. The community plugin library fills almost any gap: kanban boards, calendars, spaced repetition, Git sync.

The cost is upkeep. Plugins are written by volunteers, quality varies, and a vault with 40 plugins needs maintenance. The editor shows Markdown syntax as you write (Live Preview hides most of it), which some people love and others never get used to.

Notion is built for structured pages. A database can be a table, board, calendar, timeline or gallery of the same records, and pages can relate to each other with properties and rollups. It’s the stronger tool for a content calendar, a CRM, a team wiki or a project tracker shared with ten people. Writing long-form text in it is fine, but Notion isn’t a Markdown editor: Markdown is an import and export format, not how pages are stored.

Which one should you pick?

Pick Obsidian if:

  • You’re one person writing notes, research, journals or documentation.
  • You want files that will still open in twenty years, in any editor.
  • You work offline a lot, or don’t want an account.
  • You’re comfortable adding a few plugins.

Pick Notion if:

  • You share pages and databases with a team.
  • You need real-time editing, comments and permissions.
  • You want AI built into your workspace and you’ll pay for Business.
  • You’d rather have one polished app than assemble plugins.

Use both if you keep personal notes and work docs separate. A common split is Obsidian for your own thinking and Notion for whatever your team already lives in. If neither suits you, our Obsidian alternatives for Mac post covers Logseq, Bear, Craft, Anytype and more.

Obsidian vs Apple Notes: do you need more than the built-in app?

Many people searching Obsidian vs Notion would be happy with Apple Notes. It’s free, already on your Mac, syncs to your iPhone through iCloud, and handles checklists, tables, tags, folders, scanned documents and locked notes. On macOS you can even keep notes only on your Mac with the On My Mac account.

Where Obsidian wins:

  • Files you own. Apple Notes stores notes in its own database; Obsidian stores Markdown files.
  • Linking. Obsidian’s backlinks and graph are far ahead.
  • Cross-platform. Obsidian runs on Windows, Linux and Android too.
  • Extensibility. Plugins, themes and CSS snippets.

If you mostly jot things down and look them up later, Apple Notes is enough. Our guide to the best notes app for Mac compares it with other simple options.

Bear vs Obsidian: which Markdown app is nicer on a Mac?

Bear is a native Mac, iPhone and iPad app that also uses Markdown, and it’s the one people most often compare with Obsidian on Apple devices.

  • Bear feels more polished out of the box: a clean editor that hides Markdown as you type, nested tags instead of folders, and quick sync through iCloud. Bear Pro costs $2.99 a month or $29.99 a year and adds iCloud sync, OCR search in images and PDFs, more themes, encryption and extra export formats (bear.app).
  • Obsidian is cross-platform, file-based and far more extensible. Bear keeps notes in its own database and exports Markdown; Obsidian’s files are the notes.

Pick Bear if you only use Apple devices and want a beautiful writing app with no setup. Pick Obsidian if you need Windows or Android, links between notes, or plugins.

Where does a quick notes tool fit next to either?

Both Obsidian and Notion are full apps you open into. Some notes don’t need that: a checklist for today, a command you keep looking up, meeting notes you’ll tidy later.

FavTray Notes is one option for that, inside FavTray, a macOS menu bar app. It’s a small page-based notes tool, not a replacement for either app:

  • Nested pages with checklists, toggles, callouts, code blocks, tables and columns, using a / menu and Markdown shortcuts.
  • Each page is one JSON file in ~/.config/FavTray/Notes on your Mac. No account, no FavTray server.
  • Copy as Markdown takes a page out, so a note can move into your Obsidian vault or a Notion page when it’s ready.

Limits, honestly: no sync, no sharing, no collaboration and no mobile app. It’s for one person on one Mac. Free creates 2 notes; Pro is a one-time $4.99 for unlimited notes, with a 7-day trial and no card. Details on the Notes feature page and pricing. If you only want sticky-style reminders on screen, see our sticky notes for Mac guide instead.

Bottom line

For Obsidian vs Notion, decide where you want your notes to live. If the answer is “on my Mac, as files I own”, choose Obsidian: it’s free, offline and will outlast any company. If the answer is “somewhere my team can edit with me”, choose Notion, and budget $20 per member a month if you want its full AI. Plenty of people end up running both, and that’s a perfectly sensible answer.

Before you commit to either, test the exit: export ten notes and open them somewhere else. The app whose exports you’re happy with is the one you can safely trust with years of notes.

Try FavTray Free

One free Mac menu bar app: notch island, ports, keep-awake, clipboard, eye rest, and Claude and Codex limits.

Download Free

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Obsidian better than Notion?

It depends on the job. Obsidian is better for one person who writes a lot and wants plain Markdown files on their own disk that work offline. Notion is better for teams, shared databases and real-time editing. Many people use Obsidian for personal notes and Notion for work.

Is Obsidian free for commercial use?

Yes. As of November 2026, Obsidian's pricing page says the app is free without limits and that you are not required to pay for a commercial licence. Organisations can still buy one at $50 per user per year to support development. Sync and Publish are separate paid add-ons.

How much do Obsidian Sync and Notion cost?

Obsidian Sync is $4 a month billed yearly or $5 billed monthly, and Publish is $8 or $10 a month per site, as of November 2026. Notion is free for one person, then Plus is $10 and Business $20 per member a month billed monthly, with up to 20% off yearly. Notion's full AI features come with Business and Enterprise.

Does Notion work offline like Obsidian?

Only partly. Notion's desktop and mobile apps can keep pages for offline use, but on the Free plan you choose which pages to download, while paid plans download Recents and Favorites automatically. Obsidian works offline with no setup, because your notes are files on your Mac.

Should I use Obsidian or Apple Notes?

Use Apple Notes if you want quick notes that sync to your iPhone through iCloud with zero setup. Use Obsidian if you want Markdown files, links between notes, plugins and a folder you control. Apple Notes can also keep notes only on your Mac with the On My Mac account.